THREE CUPS OF TEA by Greg Mortenson and David Oliver Relin
Reviewed by Mary Stein, Friday Morning Book Club
...take our poll!
(May 8, 2008) Three Cups of Tea is a fascinating
nonfiction account about Greg Martenson, an American mountain climber.
In 1993, Mortenson attempted to reach the top of K2, the word's second
highest peak, to commemorate the life of his deceased sister. He fails,
and during his descent loses his way, is found and nursed back to health
by the villagers of Karpe. In trying to repay their kindness, he finds
his life's work.
While in Karpe, Mortenson sees eighty children with sticks in hand, quietly
practicing their times tables by scratching numbers in the dirt. There
is no teacher with them. There is no school house. They are in the cold
open air on a mountain top, practicing what they learned from an itinerant
teacher who stops by three times a week. Mortenson is touched by these
children and decides to build a school for them. In the process of figuring
out how to accomplish his goals, Mortenson learns about the complexity
of village cultures in Pakistan and later, Afghanistan.
Three Cups of Tea shows us how Mortenson, a man without
financial means, manages to raise funds and build a school for the village
of Karpe, and then continues his work by building schools for many other
villages in Pakistan and Afghanistan. He is a man driven by his tremendous
passion. He is an educational visionary with a wonderful "can do" American
attitude. Our book club was deeply moved by the achievements of this exceptional
man - so much so, that we decided to contribute to his nonprofit organization.*
Several people in our group commented that Three Cups of Tea
shows us a way to achieve peace: caring for children and working with
other human beings to bring needed education to children. Mortenson built
over fifty schools, mostly for girls. Our book club also discussed Mortenson's
personal challenges and passions. One person questioned the value of his
risking his life to climb to the top of a mountain, but applauded Mortenson's
equally challenging passion to help poor children achieve an education.
We also talked about the "age old question" of "nurture versus nature."
Mortenson grew up in Africa with his parents who were missionaries. How
much did his upbringing lead to his commitment to help people in other
countries? How does one become driven to help others when it means sleeping
in hovels, having little or no money for your own family, and not being
with your family for months at a time? How does one become obsessed and
stay committed to the obsession? How is it best to fight Al-Quaeda --
with guns or with schools for poor people who do not want to be part of
Al Quaeda or the Taliban, but want education and a better life for their
Mortenson's Three Cups of Tea provided us with a great
deal to think about and talk about. Our book club thought that Three
Cups of Tea would be an excellent choice for high school reading
lists and for everyone's personal library. The writing may not be high
literature, but the subject matter is inspiring.
* Greg Mortenson's nonprofit organization: Central Asia Institute, P.O.
Box 7209, Bozeman, MT 59771, 406-585-7841, ikat.org
FROM THE EDITORS: Find reviews contributed
by other local book clubs at: www.larchmontgazette.com. We'd
love to hear from other Larchmont book clubs and readers;
email us at firstname.lastname@example.org.